Short answer: pick the provider who starts by asking what your people need to do differently, can teach in English and Mandarin, shows you real China case studies with numbers, and tells you how they will check the training worked. This guide gives you eight questions to ask, the red flags to watch for, and a checklist for your next vendor meeting.
China has thousands of training companies, and most of them look the same on a website. For an HR or L&D team at a multinational, the hard part is not finding a provider. It is telling the difference between a provider who will change how your people work and one who will deliver a pleasant day and a certificate. After 25 years of running programmes for multinationals in Shanghai, Beijing and across Asia, these are the questions we would ask if we were in your seat.
1. Do they start with the business problem or the course catalogue?
A good provider asks about your people before they talk about their courses. What are managers doing now? What should they be doing in three months? How will you know? If the first thing you receive is a brochure of 200 course titles, the programme will probably be chosen off a shelf, not built for you.
Ask: "Before you propose anything, what do you need to know about our team?"
2. Can they teach in English, Mandarin, or both?
Most multinational teams in China are mixed. Senior staff may prefer English, while frontline managers often learn faster in Mandarin. Check that the provider has trainers who are genuinely fluent in both languages, not a trainer plus an interpreter. Interpretation halves the practice time.
When ALPLA, the Austrian packaging company, ran a leadership programme for its China managers, it ran English and Mandarin groups side by side, so every manager could learn in the language they think in. Read the ALPLA case study.
Ask: "Can you run the same programme in both languages, with trainers who are native or fully fluent?"
3. Who will actually be in the room?
Sales teams sell, trainers train. Find out who will deliver your programme and what they did before they became a trainer. People who have managed teams and run businesses win the trust of senior participants in the first ten minutes. Ask for a short call with the trainer, or invite them to run a sample session.
Ask: "Can we meet the trainer before we sign, and see them run a short demo?"
4. How much of the day is practice?
Behaviour changes through practice and feedback, not slides. A useful rule of thumb: participants should spend more time doing than listening. Look at the provider's agenda and count the minutes of role play, real cases and feedback. At ClarkMorgan we use a four-step method, T.A.P.E. (Theory, Application, Practice, Evaluation), so only the theory people need comes first and most of the time goes to practising real work situations.
Ask: "Show me a sample agenda. Where is the practice, and what feedback do people get?"
5. Do they have China case studies with real numbers?
Training that works in New York or London does not always work in Shanghai. Ask for case studies from companies like yours, in China, with the scope spelled out: how many people, which cities, how long, what changed. Vague testimonials are easy to collect. Specifics are not.
That means detail like a feedback culture programme for 1,000 Luxottica staff in three cities, or a one-day team building event for 120 people at a Japanese car maker. See more in Client Success.
Ask: "Can you share two case studies from multinationals in China, with numbers?"
6. Will they use your real situations?
Generic cases waste time. The best programmes use your meetings, your customers and your challenges: reporting to a regional HQ, influencing peers in other countries, leading a team that spans languages and generations. Expect the provider to talk to a few participants or their managers first and build the exercises from what they hear.
Ask: "How will you tailor the cases and role plays to our business?"
7. How will they measure results and follow up?
A workshop on its own fades fast. Ask what happens before and after the training day: pre-work, manager briefings, action plans, follow-up sessions or coaching. Ask how they will report results, from participant feedback to changes in business measures. Assessments such as MBTI, DISC, Hogan or 360 feedback can set a useful baseline when they fit the goal. For one practical way to estimate return, read The Key to ROI in Training.
Ask: "What will we see from you three months after the training?"
8. Can they handle the practical side in China?
Check the basics early. Can they deliver face to face in your cities and online? Can they work with your procurement process and issue a local VAT invoice (fapiao)? Who is your day-to-day contact? A provider with offices in the cities where you operate makes scheduling, venue visits and last-minute changes far easier.
Ask: "Who is our contact, which cities can you cover, and how do you invoice?"
Red flags
- A fixed course catalogue with no questions about your team
- One trainer for every topic, or a different trainer from the one you met
- Mostly lecture, with practice squeezed into the last hour
- Case studies without names, numbers or dates
- No plan for what happens after the training day
- An interpreter offered instead of trainers who teach in Mandarin
Checklist for your vendor meeting
| Question | What a good answer sounds like |
|---|---|
| What do you need to know about our team? | Questions about current behaviour, goals and how success will be measured |
| Which languages? | English and Mandarin delivery by fluent trainers, both groups if needed |
| Who delivers? | A named trainer with business experience you can meet first |
| How much practice? | More time practising than listening, with feedback on real cases |
| Proof? | China case studies from multinationals, with numbers |
| Tailoring? | Conversations before the programme, exercises built from your situations |
| Follow-up? | Action plans, manager involvement and a report on results |
| Practicalities? | Local offices, online option, local invoicing, one clear contact |
Frequently asked questions
How long does a corporate training programme usually take?
It depends on the goal. A focused skill such as presenting or giving feedback can start with a one or two-day workshop plus follow-up. Leadership development usually works best as a series of modules over several months. ALPLA's management programme ran 14 days over two years.
Is online training as effective as face to face?
For short, focused topics, live online sessions work well and suit teams spread across cities. For leadership programmes and anything with a lot of role play, most clients mix the two: face to face for the core workshops, online for follow-up.
Should we choose a global provider or a local one?
Look for both in one provider: international standards and content, plus trainers who know how work actually gets done in China. Ask how long they have worked with multinationals here and who their trainers are.
What should we prepare before talking to providers?
Write down who the participants are, what you want them to do differently, where they are based, which language they prefer and your rough timing. That one page will get you much better proposals.
Want a second opinion on a training plan? Tell us about your team and we will reply within 2 working days.
Related training: Training Solutions